Skip to content

Your child's first debate: how it works and how to help

By QSDebate · · 5 min read

An empty classroom with rows of desks facing a blackboard.

A first debate is a big night for a young speaker, and often for the parent watching too. Debates are a lot more predictable than they look, though.

How the night runs

Two teams argue opposite sides of one topic, and an adjudicator decides which team argued better. The whole thing usually takes under an hour.

Both teams arrive early and are told the room and the topic details they need. They either get preparation time together or arrive with a case they’ve prepared beforehand. Speakers then alternate (affirmative, negative, affirmative, negative) until everyone has spoken, and the adjudicator announces the result and explains why.

Speech lengths, team sizes, prep time and whether topics come out in advance all vary between competitions, year levels and schools. If your child debates through school, the teacher in charge is the quickest way to get the real details. Our parent’s guide to QDU debating covers the Queensland picture in more depth.

Nerves are normal

Shaky hands, a dry mouth, a racing heart and the sudden certainty they’ve forgotten everything. It’s the standard first-debate experience, and nothing to worry about.

Nerves are almost always worst in the ten minutes before speaking, and they shrink with repetition far more than with reassurance. The second debate is easier than the first, and the fifth is easier again.

The three speakers

Most school debates have three speakers per team, and knowing their jobs takes a surprising amount of fear out of the room.

Speaker Main job
First speaker Sets up the team’s case, explains how they read the topic, and gives their own arguments.
Second speaker Responds to the other team (rebuttal), then adds the team’s remaining arguments.
Third speaker Mostly rebuttal: explains why the other team’s case does not hold up, then sums up the debate.

Some formats add a short reply speech at the end, and some limit which speakers can bring in new arguments.

How it’s judged

The adjudicator scores each speaker on what they said, how they said it and how well it was organised. You’ll often hear these called matter, manner and method. Louder isn’t better, and the more confident-looking team doesn’t automatically win.

A quiet speaker who answers the other team’s arguments directly will usually score better than a polished speaker who ignores them.

Most adjudicators give a short spoken explanation afterwards, which tells your child exactly what to work on next.

The week before

  • Get them practising out loud and standing up. Two or three times is enough, and reading a speech silently doesn’t count.
  • Time it. Running over time is the most common avoidable problem for new speakers.
  • Pick one thing to praise and, at most, one thing to change.
  • Sort out the practical stuff early - uniform, transport, water bottle, cue cards, and leaving with time to spare.
  • Agree on what “going well” means. “I said all three of my arguments and looked up twice” is a goal your child controls. “We win” isn’t.
  • Protect their sleep the night before.

Starting from scratch? Our Junior Speakers and Primary Debating classes teach speech structure, rebuttal and note-taking, with regular speaking turns for everyone. Get in touch with your child’s year level and how much speaking they’ve done, and we’re happy to talk it through before you commit to anything.

On the night

Get there early, sit where they can see a friendly face, and then let it be their debate. Please don’t mouth words, whisper prompts or hold up notes. It rattles speakers and can breach the rules.

Stay for the adjudication and jot down the feedback, because your child will remember almost none of it. And be ready for a loss. Plenty of good first debates are losses.

Afterwards

Start with something specific they did. It shows you were actually watching, and it gives them something to repeat next time.

Instead of Try
“You were amazing!” “Your second argument was really clear. You gave a reason and then an example.”
“Did you win?” “What was the hardest moment?”
“You should have said…” “What did the adjudicator suggest?”
“You didn’t look nervous.” “You kept going after you lost your place. That’s the hard part.”

Save any real coaching for a day or two later, once the adrenaline has gone. If they’re flat about the result, it’s enough to agree that losing is annoying.

What if my child hated it?

Ask what was bad before you decide anything. “I hated it” often turns out to mean one moment, like losing their place, a hard question or an unkind comment.

Most students who stick with debating disliked at least part of their first one. If your child is willing to try a second, there’s a good chance it goes very differently. If the dread is bigger than that, a smaller and lower-pressure setting is a better next step than pushing through.

Keep reading

See a class for yourself

A free trial is the quickest way to find out whether debating suits your child.

Book a free class